Valentine's Day
Director: Gary Marshall
Year: 2010
In the vein of movies like Love Actually and He’s Just Not That Into You comes Valentine’s Day. The latest romantic comedy from Gary Marshall, director of, among other things, Pretty Woman. And just like those two, this movie features a huge star-studded ensemble cast, but unlike them, all the stories featured don’t work nearly as well and in the end it just feels like a convoluted mess.
The plot is hard to describe given the unusual structure of the movie, but the film is centered around several couples during Valentine’s Day. You get to see how they fall in love with one another, breaking up only to get together at the end…the usual stuff. And just like Love Actually, the stories are not only about beautiful people in their 20s; it also features a few of stories about young couples.
The movie’s biggest problem is that it doesn’t give the characters enough development and it struggles to fit every story into its 125 minutes run. Sometimes the characters disappear completely for a long time and just when you’ve completely forgotten about them, they reappear out of nowhere. There’s a nice sense of connection between each of the stories though. But even that can’t save it from being messy.
It doesn’t help that it is extremely predictable too, not one of the plot twists at the end is not seen coming way before it happens. Moreover, it has a bunch of romantic movies clichés, which wouldn’t necessarily be a bad thing, had they been well executed, but so many in such a little time can get tiresome. You’ve got the usual friends who don’t realize they love each other until the end of the movie, the kid in love with his teacher, the cheerleader and the jock, guy misunderstanding phone call, etc.
The cast is filled with stars, not one of the roles (even the supporting ones) features an unrecognizable face. The problem is that not one of them is really into it; they’re all there waiting to finish their lines so they can get paid. The result is a bunch of robotic performances, especially from Taylor Lautner, who’s just there smiling and making millions of fangirls faint in the process…but not acting. There are a few moments of enjoyment, mostly provided by George Lopez in his role as Ashton Kutcher’s immigrant co-worker. Other big stars in the movie are Jessica Biel, incredibly miscast as a woman without a date on valentine’s, like I’m supposed to believe that Jessica Biel of all people can’t find a date on Valentine’s; Jamie Foxx as the token black guy, Eric Dane as an aging football star and his grey’s Anatomy co-star Patrick Dempsey as a doctor cheating on his wife, among others.
Valentine’s Day had a potential, with such a big cast it could’ve been a great doppelganger to Love Actually, but sadly it fails at being nearly as romantic or funny as that movie, and in the end nothing works quite the way it should, and that’s disappointing.
